KiwiBuild and the problem with overpromising and under-delivering

by The Listener / 20 June, 2019
RelatedArticlesModule - KiwiBuild nz

Photo/Getty Images

Just days away from July 1, the date that the Government promised 1000 new houses would have been built under its flagship KiwiBuild policy – with 5000 next year and 10,000 the following year – the failure of the programme can be seen in perspective. So far, 119 KiwiBuild homes have been completed.

The biggest loss is not the houses. After all, they never existed. Other than hopes being dashed by people who might have qualified for a KiwiBuild home, the biggest blow is to the Government’s reputation.

It’s good intentions are not in doubt, but nor can there be doubt that, believing its own rhetoric, it overpromised. In Opposition, Labour implied that the solution to housing affordability was simple: it promised 100,000 affordable homes in 10 years, half in Auckland.

There were always serious problems with this. Any political party that promises anything over 10 years, when it is elected for only three, deserves scepticism.

As it has transpired, even two years has proved too difficult for Labour to make inroads into the policy that it trumpeted while the National-led government flailed in its own attempts to improve affordability. Among tactics National tried were loosening local body restrictions, expanding social housing to non-government providers, and reforming the Resource Management Act. But its efforts were no match for rampant house-price inflation.

The housing market primarily comprises private buyers and private sellers and governments, as we have seen, have little influence. Labour might have gained at least some traction if it had immediately focused on its Ministry of Housing and Urban Development legislation, which aims to force councils to free up land and promote better co-ordination of infrastructure building. Yet it did not.

The Government also struggles with public expectations – again, largely of its own creation – that it can do a better job than National of supporting society’s most disadvantaged. There is demand for more targeting so that help goes to those in greatest need. However, governments must also contend with the fact that people who earn $70,000 and are in the top tax bracket, although meeting no one’s definition of “rich”, also want fairness. Universal policies, such as fees-free for the first year of tertiary education – the Government has gone deathly quiet on its promise of extending it to two, then three years – at least make middle- and upper-income earners feel as though they, too, are getting something back for their taxes. Yes, it is their own money that pays for it. Both the argument and the money quickly become circular.

The belief that only a government can put right social problems, no matter how serious and ingrained, is in Labour’s DNA. It was articulated by former Labour finance minister Sir Michael Cullen in 2007 when he said, “Only the active and redemptive power of the state can address, at all adequately, issues of serious deprivation – not random acts of charity, however welcome and well meant.”

Yet problems such as social housing, housing affordability and welfare dependency are complex and entrenched and the state is not automatically better than anyone else at providing every service. Ask any alcoholic who has experienced the genuine transformation of finding sobriety with the aid of the Salvation Army and Alcoholics Anonymous, for example.

The philosophy articulated by Cullen can, however, be seen a generation later in the Government’s overpromising on the likes of KiwiBuild and in Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern personally taking on the child-poverty reduction portfolio. The Government’s official targets include the aim to more than halve child poverty in 10 years. Yet, sadly, by some measures, poverty is getting worse.

The problems that exist in housing affordability, or among the most disadvantaged, are not the result of previous governments not caring enough. With the possible exception of National’s infamous 1991 “mother of all Budgets” that cut welfare benefits in real terms, New Zealand governments have always cared about fairness, because New Zealand voters care about it. The last government’s move to raise benefit payments in real terms for the first time in 43 years was the right thing to do.

Voters want to feel confident about issues of fairness and also that this Government knows what it is doing, especially as economic forecasts become increasingly gloomy, and immigration falls. Building such confidence could, however, turn out to be even harder than building houses.

This editorial was first published in the June 29, 2019 issue of the New Zealand Listener.


Bruce Springsteen’s cinematic new album heads into cowboy country
108195 2019-07-22 00:00:00Z Music

Bruce Springsteen’s cinematic new album heads into…

by James Belfield

The stars in the title of Bruce Springsteen’s 19th album aren’t just those shining down on the hardscrabble American lives that have long inhabited...

Read more
What you need to know about your vitamin D levels in winter
108187 2019-07-22 00:00:00Z Health

What you need to know about your vitamin D levels…

by Nicky Pellegrino

Vitamin D is essential for bone health, and exposure to winter sun is a good way to maintain it.

Read more
Humans aren't designed to be happy – so stop trying
108639 2019-07-22 00:00:00Z Psychology

Humans aren't designed to be happy – so stop tryin…

by Rafael Euba

Chasing the happiness dream is a very American concept, exported to the rest of the world through popular culture.

Read more
Kiwi pies filling gap in Chinese market
108684 2019-07-22 00:00:00Z Food

Kiwi pies filling gap in Chinese market

by Siobhan Downes

If you’re ever in China and find yourself hankering for a pie, one Kiwi couple has you covered.

Read more
Bill Ralston: We're in for fireworks if John Banks runs for mayor
108531 2019-07-21 00:00:00Z Politics

Bill Ralston: We're in for fireworks if John Banks…

by Bill Ralston

If John Banks joins Auckland’s mayoral race, there's a chance he could rise from the political dead.

Read more
Once were Anzacs: The epic history of Māori soldiers in WWI
108382 2019-07-21 00:00:00Z History

Once were Anzacs: The epic history of Māori soldie…

by Peter Calder

The role of Māori soldiers in World War I has long been relegated to footnotes, but a major new work by historian Monty Soutar re-examines their...

Read more
The new Lion King lacks the original's claws
108533 2019-07-21 00:00:00Z Movies

The new Lion King lacks the original's claws

by Russell Baillie

A naturalistic remake of the 1994 Disney hit cartoon musical will bring in the dough, but it just doesn't quite work.

Read more
50th moon landing anniversary: New Zealand's forgotten Nasa legend
108468 2019-07-20 00:00:00Z History

50th moon landing anniversary: New Zealand's forgo…

by Peter Griffin

Today marks 50 years since humans landed on the Moon, a feat achieved thanks to Kiwi scientist William Pickering and his team.

Read more